is it too much to ask?

Will never be, people seem to be affraid to make noise

Doubt it but it could be its own thing in its own right....just got to cut out singing that bloody "fathers gun" song all the time......that gets sung more than old Faithful and that is our battle cry...not some poxy song about them red & white bstards

Don't think it ever will be, but getting the crowd numbers back up and watching a good team would help. More and more people have moved over to the South and West stands in recent years, which makes the crowd more spread out.

Never

The threepenny wasn't the threepenny for the last 15 years or so before we left anyway

Only if it gets changed to all standing. The best atmosphere comes from terraces where people that want to sing can move and stand together.

So you didn't sing at wembley then?

I agree with FC Baldy, why do we persist with singing songs about Rovers?

Rip the seats out and make it a stand would be a step in the right direction for me. All seaters are crap IMO. Agree with Jake as well, Threepenny wasn't the same once the H&S started ripping into it and reducing the capacity etc.

you might not have the threepenny stand anymore but the tradition of bricking coaches til you've smashed the windows lives on! at least 1 coach done again today

Eh? Is the only alternative to the best atmosphere: "no singing"?



And are you really trying to compare the atmosphere at a huge event like the Challenge Cup Final involving around 30k Hull fans all sat together with the atmosphere at a run-of-the-mill league game involving 11k fans spread out across 4 stands? You're comparing apples and oranges there.



A terrible riposte.