Well said vasty. Whilst that game v Bradford was a bad day all round sammut moved out of the way purposely on not one but two occasions opening up a gap for a score. Richard agar even mentioned it in his post match interview without actually naming the player.

I see that Walshaw is out on loan to Dewsbury. We could get him back and see if he is the answer many thought he was.



Part of me looks on this as a sign we made the right decision as he hasn't kicked on even at a lower level, but it is a shame if that's the case as I thought he had potential. Hull away he was breaking for fun but ultimately the lack of the pass meant he was heading for the second row where you are competing with bruising tacklers as well and they are often needed more.

Walshaw has impressed when given the chance. But is behind Pitts Ferguson and Olbison.

Current centre options are Ryan and Arundel, there is a place for Walshaw right there.

Personally I would much rather see us going after another keinhorst type player, a good centre at a good club only not playing because there are very good players ahead of them.



Walshaw is no particular improvement on Ryan IMO. Having said that, if we were looking to replace Ryan then Walshaw would be a fair call. But not as a replacement for Collis.

Notice Luke George has been playing in Oz for Northern Pride. Not many players who don't improve after a stint in Australia and George was already better than Lyne or Arundal and still only 26.

And injured more than Collis who many we're glad to see leave for this reason.

Is he really

Thought Collis was a good player.

He once was

I'd take a fit Luke George no problem, but to be fair, right now id take 3 or 4 players who have played at a half decent level from anywhere? Positions are almost irrelevant.

We have too many in the squad who are in the wrong mindset. Losing and certain bad habits have become the norm and i dont think they know how to change it. BS can only do so much.

I'd work on partnerships to improve that bad habits piece



If we recruit a centre we need one who can specifically give the ball to Johnstone.

Just like (I think) Sio will improve Godinet and keep him zipping around the field.

Anyone with a long kicking game with improve Smith as it will take that pressure off him (I thought this would be Hall)



A fullback that can organise the defence will help everyone's confidence.