I know its probably been done to death but which would you rather win?



Im a KR Fan and without stating the obvious its now only possible for us to win the GF however i would rather of been at Wembley on Sat with a chance of the CC than in the GF simply because i am of the opinion that the team who wins the league are the best not the GF winners.



What would you folks take if offered at the start of the season?

challenge cup we've already won recently, so grand final for me now, although that prospect looks a few years off atm





still think the cc is bigger than the gf due to tv audiences

The Grand Final is the one that gives you the right to chant 'Champions' all season so that is the bigger one.



The only fans I've ever heard belittle the Challenge Cup have been the Leeds fans. They also belittled the league leaders trophy until last week too. Funny pattern appearing there.

Clearly the Grand Final. That decides the best team of the year, the champions.

There shouldn't even be a trophy for that.

but all the saints players moaned and whinged

I think the grand final is gradually being devalued by being an 8 team play off, so I,m favouring the Challenge Cup.

Challenge Cup is media worldwide and promotes the game, Grand Final is for Sky Viewers only.

For what it's worth the Challenge Cup IMO has the edge.



All the pro RFL teams have a chance of being involved as do a lot the amateurs so its a competition for all and very simple and straight forward!



To get the SL GF however is an exercise based around rewarding failure except for the top team!

FWIW,I really thought the CC was dying a slow death,what with the low attendances in the earlier rounds,but went to New Wembley Saturday and thought it was superb.If people knock the CC just try telling that to the wire fans down there.The GF is mainly for the 2 teams involved but the CC looks like the whole Rugby League family get together.....

The CC was dying because the RFL devalued it and moved it to the back end of the season and concentrated on the Superleague being the saviour of rugby league.

The Aussies would have loved to have this traditonal competiiton, whats best about the Challege Cup is its identity with all fans from amateur to professional level, its legends and its place in sporting history.

The CC has what SL is trying to take away from RL, HISTORY, UNITY and IDENTITY !!!!!!!!!!!!!

From a fans point of view I enjoy the CC final better than grand final.



The cc is good weekend away in the sunshine while the grand final is always played in cold and rain.