he would cost less than most as there would be no compo to pay out

Aside from to Slick Mick

Presume slick would become assistant, so still no compo, clegg or foggy to pay out !

Saints aint wigan so i would welcome him to our club, must be better than potter who as failed when it's mattered.

You mean like Anderson in his first year?

Woah, Woah, Woah.



Have you not read the warnings that common sense is not welcome round here.



I am going to rename the site KneeJerkers.com

Yes i would.

Noble is not a good enough coach for clubs like Wigan and Saints.



He could do a great job at Celtic, Salford, Quins....

i agree with this, he can coach a team, but isn't very good at squad building, which teams like wigan 4/5 years ago and saints now, need

I don't understand how you can say he hasn't improved us in the last 3 years. Are you not aware of what position we was in before he took over? I'm pretty sure you aren't that clueless. We may not have made any finals but we have almoast been there which is a dam sight better than before he was here. Our youth system has also improved since Noble's been here from the 18's, 21's and plenty of those who have featured in the first team under Noble.

Noble is a good coach as his record shows. People forget he's taken Wigan 80 mins from the last 2 grand finals and his record at bulls is also pretty good.



On noble not building a good squad, I wonder how many of wigans signings have come from noble.

Since he came we've been 80 minutes from the grand final (twice) and eighty minutes from the Challenge Cup final (twice).



The reserves last year won the grand final and are through again this year.

Th academy team reached the grand final last year and are through to the elimination semi this weekend after finishing second in their league (with a very young side)



I'd give Noble one more year but it isn't going to happen. Watch out for a big shake up in the coaching regime(s) at Wigan.